On Correct Answers

On Correct Answers

Correct answers exist mostly for questions we've already agreed how to answer.

Correct answers can only be given to questions whose answers we've already decided to consider correct.

In what year was Pushkin born? Obviously, 1799. But it's 1799 only because we wrote it down and agreed that this particular year would be called 1799. The number is a convention we share, not something written into the sky.

Even the day shows it. Russia still used the Julian calendar when Pushkin was born, so his birthday is recorded as 26 May by the old style and 6 June by the new. One birth, two correct dates, depending on which agreement you've signed up to.

So questions about things we genuinely don't know can't have straightforwardly "correct" answers. Of course, someone might solve a mathematical problem and produce an answer nobody had before. A scientist checks the solution and cries "Bravo!" But the method rests entirely on rules we had already accepted as valid. The answer is new; the ground it stands on isn't.

That's why proving a hundred theorems may be easier than proving the existence of God. I don't know about you, but I wouldn't pursue the latter with much fanaticism.

I find this freeing rather than troubling. Everyone has their own misconceptions; truth belongs to everyone. When someone insists their answer to an open question is the correct one, it's worth asking which agreement they're standing on, and whether you've signed it too.